On September 1, 2022, while playing for her high-school volleyball team, female volleyball athlete Payton McNabb was struck in the head by a ball spiked by a competitor on the opposing team. According to her testimony, the blow knocked her unconscious for roughly 30 seconds and provoked a “fencing response” (a neurological reaction in response to a concussion where the person’s arms suddenly go rigid and extend) immediately after impact. [^] She also reports long-term injuries: partial paralysis on her right side, impaired vision, cognitive issues, persistent headaches, balance problems and anxiety. [^] Note that this type of injury is very rare in volleyball and more commonly seen in high impact sports like football.
McNabb’s athletic career was ended. As outlined in her testimony, what had been a three-sport high school athlete’s trajectory changed dramatically following the injury. [^] She went on to testify before the North Carolina General Assembly (April 2023) in support of the “Fairness in Women’s Sports” bill, stating:
“I may be the first to come before you with an injury, but if this doesn’t pass I won’t be the last.” [^]
She suffered partial paralysis on one side, visual issues, balance problems, and chronic headaches. [^] Many of these symptoms continue years later.
The incident has been cited in legislative hearings and policy debates across various U.S. states as an example of potential physical risk and fairness issues in single-sex female sports categories. [^]
More Info
- Payton McNabb’s testimony
- https://www.independentwomen.com/people/payton-mcnabb/—bio
- https://www.congress.gov/119/meeting/house/118215/witnesses/HHRG-119-GO16-Bio-McNabbP-20250507.pdf—bio
- Legislation to try to stop this and how the votes went can be found here and here.